Seedance vs Wan vs Grok Imagine: the same still, three video models
From the same still and almost the same prompt, Seedance 2.0 Mini made the clearest camera push-in with ambient sound, Wan 3.0 kept the frame steadier and added an approaching car, and Grok Imagine 1.5 made a longer clip with subtler motion that cost far more. A 5-second 480p Seedance 2.0 Mini clip costs $0.15.
Animate a film still
A desert motel at blue hour with a red neon sign, made with Nano Banana 2, used as the first frame. The prompt asks for a slow push-in, a flickering sign and a passing car. It tests camera motion, how much of the still survives and the sound. 16:9 at 480p, one run each.
Slow cinematic push-in toward the roadside motel at blue hour. The red neon sign flickers softly, a distant car passes on the highway with its headlights sweeping the road, stars twinkle, gentle film grain. Static mood, no people.How they did
| Model | Did well | Fell short |
|---|---|---|
| Seedance 2.0 Mini | A clear push-in toward the motel, with ambient sound, in 5 seconds. | The camera wanders before it settles into the push-in, so the framing moves further from the still than in Wan's clip. |
| Wan 3.0 | The steadiest frame, and a car approaching with its headlights on, close to what the prompt described. | Less camera movement than Seedance, so the push-in is harder to see. |
| Grok Imagine 1.5 | An 8-second clip, its default length, with subtle motion. | A smaller frame size than the other two, and it cost far more at these settings. |
How we tested
All three clips start from the same Nano Banana 2 still of a desert motel, used as the first frame. Each model ran at 16:9 and 480p with the same prompt, except that the Seedance run's last line also said "Static mood"; everything else stayed at the model's default. Seedance 2.0 Mini was set to 5 seconds; Wan 3.0 and Grok Imagine 1.5 used their default length, which came out at about 5 seconds for Wan and 8 for Grok. We ran each model once on 2026-11-05 and show the first take, with no retries and no edits.
The credits under each result come from the model registry and are today's prices at those settings. Frame sizes differ because each model picks its own pixel size for 480p. One run per model is a small sample, so use it to see how each model tends to move a still, then test your own image.
What to take from it
- For a visible camera move, start with Seedance 2.0 Mini. It is also the lowest-cost Seedance tier, which makes it a good draft model.
- For a steady frame that follows the action in the prompt, try Wan 3.0.
- Set the duration yourself. Grok Imagine 1.5 makes 1-15 second clips; asking for 5 seconds keeps the comparison fair and the cost down.
- Need longer or sharper? Seedance 2.5, Wan 3.0 and Kling 4.0 go up to 30 seconds and higher resolutions. See image to video for the full list.
Questions
Which is better for image to video, Seedance or Wan?
In our test Seedance 2.0 Mini made the more visible camera move, and Wan 3.0 kept the frame steadier and followed the passing-car part of the prompt. Try both at 480p on your own still before rendering a final; Wan 3.0 opens after your first credit purchase.
Can I use Seedance in ChatGPT or Claude?
Yes. Connect Makemancer, send your image and ask for a clip with Seedance 2.0 Mini or Seedance 2.5. The assistant quotes the cost before it runs.
Why did Grok Imagine cost more?
It made an 8-second clip, its default length, and it costs more per clip at these settings. Ask for a shorter duration to bring the cost down; the credits under each result are today's prices.
Do these clips have sound?
All three models generate audio with the video. The Seedance clip has ambient sound that fits the scene.
Were these the best of several takes?
No. Each clip is the first take from one run with the same still and aspect ratio. The prompts match word for word, except that the Seedance run ended with "Static mood".